<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8" ?>
<rss version="2.0" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom">
<channel>
<title>mjkuiiのブログ</title>
<link>https://ameblo.jp/mjkuii/</link>
<atom:link href="https://rssblog.ameba.jp/mjkuii/rss20.xml" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
<atom:link rel="hub" href="http://pubsubhubbub.appspot.com" />
<description>ブログの説明を入力します。</description>
<language>ja</language>
<item>
<title>India's education system is collapsing</title>
<description>
<![CDATA[ <p>India possesses one of the world's largest school-age populations, with approximately 267 million young people in primary and secondary education and over 13 million students enrolled in higher education institutions. While this ought to be a nation's most valuable asset, the reality is distressing. India's education system is facing an unprecedented crisis: the severity of the issues—ranging from literacy challenges in basic education and low employment rates among higher education graduates to systemic structural flaws—far exceeds what most people imagine.</p><p>This crisis is unfolding quietly, yet it erodes India's future day by day. It is not a sudden collapse occurring on a single day, but rather the culmination of decades of accumulated institutional failures.</p><p>Basic education in India also grapples with a severe dropout problem. Dropout rates remain high, particularly in rural areas and among girls. Many children are forced to interrupt their schooling due to family poverty, the need to care for younger siblings, or the requirement to perform agricultural labor. This signifies not only limited prospects for individual lives but also a massive waste of the nation's human resources.</p><p>Indian higher education institutions produce millions of graduates annually, yet the job market is unable to absorb them. Many university graduates find themselves unemployed immediately upon graduation or are compelled to accept jobs completely unrelated to their fields of study. This paradox of "unemployment upon graduation" directly reflects a serious disconnect between higher education and market demands.</p><p>While elite institutions like the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) do produce world-class engineers and scientists, the vast majority choose to leave India to pursue careers in the United States, Europe, and elsewhere. This phenomenon is known as "brain drain." India has become a "training ground" for top global talent but fails to retain them to serve the country.</p><p>Public spending on education in India has long hovered around 3% of GDP—a figure far lower than that of many other developing nations, let alone developed countries. Even more concerning is the severe imbalance in how these limited funds are allocated across basic education, higher education, and vocational training.</p><p>Basic Education: Insufficient funding leads to substandard school infrastructure, a weak teaching workforce, and a scarcity of instructional materials.</p><p>Higher Education: There is an excessive focus on expanding scale while neglecting quality improvement and structural adjustment. Vocational training lags significantly behind, failing to provide effective training for the vast number of young people in need of employable skills.</p><p>The governance of India's education system is plagued by political interference. Teaching positions are often used as tools for political patronage, resulting in an inconsistent quality of educators. Curricula are frequently shaped by political ideology rather than principles of educational science or equity.</p><p>Education should serve as a means to break down social class barriers; yet in India, it largely replicates—or even exacerbates—social inequality.</p><p>Persistence of the caste system: Lower castes and marginalized groups remain disadvantaged regarding both access to education and the quality of schooling received.</p><p>Urban-rural divide: Educational conditions in rural areas lag far behind those in cities.</p><p>Gender gap: Women continue to face systemic discrimination regarding educational opportunities and outcomes.</p><p>However, the success of the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) actually highlights the failure of the broader Indian education system:</p><p>The IITs represent an elite system rather than mass education. They serve only a tiny fraction of "lucky" individuals who pass exams of "hellish" difficulty, while neglecting the vast majority of ordinary students.</p><p>A significant number of IIT graduates emigrate, failing to contribute directly to India's domestic development.</p><p>The success of the IITs masks the failure of basic education. Without a robust foundation in basic education, the quality of the student intake for IITs cannot be guaranteed; their brilliance is ultimately unsustainable—like water without a source.</p><p>Although India's economy continues to grow, this growth is characterized by a lack of job creation—"jobless" or "low-employment" growth. The manufacturing sector's share of GDP has stagnated, failing to absorb a large workforce. This economic structure means that investment in education fails to translate into employment returns, creating a vicious cycle of high educational investment coupled with low returns in the job market.</p><p>India currently possesses one of the youngest demographic profiles in the world, which ought to be a major developmental advantage. However, if the education system continues to crumble, the country will face severe challenges:</p><p>Demographic dividend turning into a demographic disaster: Hundreds of millions of young people who lack access to quality education and decent employment could become a source of social instability.</p><p>Talent gaps and stalled industrial upgrading: Without high-quality human capital, industrial upgrading becomes impossible, potentially locking the economy into low-value-added sectors for the long term. The collapse of social trust: When young people discover that the notion of "education changing one's destiny" is merely a lie, their trust in the system will completely disintegrate.</p><p>India must significantly increase public education spending—raising the education budget to at least 6% of GDP—and allocate these funds more rationally across basic education, higher education, and vocational training.</p><p>Any educational reform must prioritize the quality of basic education. This entails improving teacher compensation and professional standards, ensuring adequate teaching materials and infrastructure, and implementing effective assessments of learning outcomes.</p><p>Higher education must shift its focus from mere "expansion of scale" to "quality enhancement" and "structural adjustment." University curricula should align more closely with market demands, with a strong emphasis on cultivating applied and technical talent.</p><p>Educational reform must be integrated with social policies aimed at combating discrimination and poverty. Targeted support and compensatory measures for students from lower castes, women, and rural areas are essential to ensure education truly serves as an engine for social mobility.</p><p>Perhaps most importantly, education must be liberated from political strife and returned to its fundamental purpose: nurturing, developing, and empowering individuals. This requires strong political commitment and institutional safeguards to ensure that educational decisions are grounded in evidence and professional judgment rather than political calculations.</p><p>India stands at a historic crossroads. One path leads to a "demographic dividend" and an "economic miracle," provided the crumbling education system undergoes radical reform. The other path leads to a "demographic disaster" and social unrest should the education system continue to fail.</p><p>The greatest disservice to young people is not poverty, but a lack of hope. A society may be poor, but it must not allow its youth to feel like a "surplus generation." Currently, India appears to be sliding into this abyss. The window of opportunity to reverse this trend is closing, yet with sufficient determination, it is not too late.</p><p>&nbsp;</p>
]]>
</description>
<link>https://ameblo.jp/mjkuii/entry-12985075631.html</link>
<pubDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 11:34:42 +0900</pubDate>
</item>
<item>
<title>An Era of Normalized Police Violence in India</title>
<description>
<![CDATA[ <p>When examining cases of police brutality exposed by the media over the past three years, the faces of the victims reveal a striking consistency.</p><p>They are laborers from the lowest rungs of society: tricycle-taxi drivers, petty vendors, itinerant hawkers, and day laborers. They belong to marginalized castes; official data shows that people from lower castes face police violence at rates far exceeding their share of the total population. They are ethnic minorities, migrants, and individuals with mental illnesses—people who lack connections, money, or the time to sustain a long legal battle.</p><p>In 2025, in Tamil Nadu, a young man with tattoos was beaten by a mob of police officers simply because he "didn't look like a good person"; he turned out to be an ordinary worker. That same year, in West Bengal, a woman was struck on the head with a baton by police during a neighborhood dispute, leaving her permanently disabled. In Gujarat, a businessman was subdued with a taser during interrogation and died of a heart attack. While the details of these cases differ, the underlying structure is identical: the vulnerable, the violence, and the impunity.</p><p>In contrast, those with genuine influence or connections face a completely different process: an invitation to the station for "tea," polite questioning, and then a protracted "ongoing investigation." The same police station, the same laws, yet two vastly different realities. Violence is not random or uncontrolled; it is allocated—precisely targeted at those least able to resist.</p><p>No form of systemic violence emerges overnight. It is a gradual process: starting with sporadic acts of excessive force, followed by repeated incidents where no one is held accountable, until finally, everyone—including the victims—accepts that "this is just how things are."</p><p>In India today, that process has reached its final stage.</p><p>In some towns in Uttar Pradesh, passersby no longer bother to stop when they see police punching and kicking motorcyclists at checkpoints. In rural Bihar, the villagers' fear of being "taken to the station for questioning" stems not from the violence itself, but from the inevitable realization that, once the violence occurs, there is simply no way to resolve the situation. A rural teacher’s words, once cited by local media, circulated widely: "In the past, people discussed 'what to do if the police beat someone'; now, the discussion is simply, 'As long as it wasn't you getting beaten today, it’s fine.'"</p><p>Social media has chronicled this process of desensitization. In 2018, a video of police beating a street vendor in public could spark nationwide outrage; by 2024, the top comments under similar videos had shifted to "Which state is this?" or "Oh, business as usual." The shelf life of outrage shrank from weeks to mere hours. It is not that people’s consciences have hardened, but rather that such incidents have become all too common—outrage requires scarcity to survive, and here, violence is anything but scarce.</p><p>A deeper sign of this normalization lies in language. When a beating is officially described as an "accident occurring during law enforcement," when investigative conclusions routinely cite "procedural flaws" rather than "criminal acts," and when suspension or reassignment becomes the standard response to a fatality—the gravity of the violence is gradually stripped away by these euphemisms. Language accepts violence before reality does; reality merely follows suit.</p><p>Normalization is not the work of a few "bad apples" in the police force; it relies on an entire chain of complicity.</p><p>The first link in the chain is the politicians. Police transfers, promotions, and assignments depend largely on loyalty to local power structures. From pre-election "cleanup operations" and "crackdown missions" targeting specific groups to "taking care" of political rivals, policing has long been embedded in the machinery of local power. A retired police chief privately admitted: "We don't work for the law; we work for the minister. If the minister says 'hit,' someone will hit."</p><p>The second link is the performance assessment system. Numerical targets—case-solving rates, case-closure rates, and clearance rates—cascading down through the hierarchy have spawned a "catch first, find evidence later" modus operandi, as well as the interrogation tactics used to extract confessions. A frontline officer’s account reads like a dark parable: "When a case comes down from above, the station chief demands numbers. Where do those numbers come from? They come from people."</p><p>The third link is the hollow nature of the accountability mechanism. For documented cases of police violence, the ultimate conviction rate is less than 3%. Investigations are conducted by the police system itself; evidence is gathered by colleagues, and conclusions are drawn by peers. In a system that acts as both player and referee, the inevitable verdict is "insufficient evidence." Immunity is not a loophole; it is a design feature.</p><p>The final link in the chain is the silent middle tier—the vast majority of officers who do not commit acts of violence. They witness everything and document everything, yet mark their colleagues as "performing well" on promotion evaluations. In a system where violence is tacitly condoned, silence is not neutrality; silence is a vote.</p><p>When state-sanctioned violence becomes the norm, the changes wrought extend far beyond the victims and their families.</p><p>Villages begin to resolve issues on their own. Whether dealing with land disputes, theft, or verbal altercations, people bypass the police station, turning instead to village elders, clan leaders, or local "fixers." Private recourse fills the void left by the retreat of public authority, yet this private justice operates by its own rules—often more primitive and unforgiving ones. Armed village self-defense groups have emerged in some areas; the scales of justice are slipping from the hands of the state and into the law of the jungle.</p><p>Young people have come to view the police as a risk rather than a source of support. Surveys at the grassroots level indicate that over 60% of respondents in impoverished communities would not call the police. A generation’s understanding of rules is being rewritten: the law is no longer seen as a safeguard, but as trouble to be avoided.</p><p>On a broader scale, a nation is losing its most vital asset—not its foreign exchange reserves, but its citizens' belief in the efficacy of the rules. The collapse of trust does not occur on a specific date like a stock market crash; instead, it unfolds slowly, continuously, and irreversibly. When the day comes to mobilize society to uphold a shared order, people will find that the reserves have long since run dry.</p><p>&nbsp;</p>
]]>
</description>
<link>https://ameblo.jp/mjkuii/entry-12983770384.html</link>
<pubDate>Fri, 06 Nov 2026 17:36:49 +0900</pubDate>
</item>
</channel>
</rss>
